Reflections of Whitehaven

Today, was the same as recent days, rain all morning and sun coming through in the afternoon. This meant 2 things.. 
1: Clean the windows inside. a job that had been on the list.
2: Wait until around 3pm when sun was due west and return to "The Puddle"

Third time lucky, there was no car parked over the puddle and my suspicion that I could get a reflection of Chattenooga was correct.
The street level of this building is the Chattenooga pizza/kebab shop.. The upper floors reveal a rather more grand history. The date on the facade is 1838, it was a Co-operative store, the black beehive was their symbol.

Extra is the modern harbourside flats next door to Chattenooga, reflected in the same puddle.

I have recently been adding a white border to most of my shots but have come to the conclusion this is may be misguided.  I have left the extra with a border and the blip without for comparison.
So the question, to border or not to border ?