Craft On Saturday - Two Cards From One Stamp

Two very different cards using the same rubber stamp.
The design on the right is stamped directly onto a piece of white card, which is then coloured.  This gives a clean look to the card.

The one on the left is stamped several times onto white card and the various elements cut out and coloured.  They are then reassembled and layered up onto backing card using foam pads.  This gives  dimension to the finished card.  I like both versions equally, I wonder what someone looking at the two cards together would chose.